Is China triggering a global crisis?

由于受到股市危机影响,中国经济增速放缓至近20年来最低水平。瑞士洛桑国际管理学院金融学教授Nuno Fernandes的文章详细分析了中国经济困境背后的深层原因,包括影子银行、过度负债和陈旧失衡的税制,并指出从预算支出上看尚属贫穷的中国,却面临着富国的种种问题。
Amid stock market crisis, China’s economic growth has slowed to its lowest rate in over two decades.  Nuno Fernandes, a Professor of Finance at IMD, writes to shed light on what behind China’s economic woes – from shadow banking and massive debt to an archaic and biased tax system, pointing out that China faces rich country’s problems on a poor country budget. 

The recent steep slides on global stock markets have been a long time in the making. As early as two years ago, it was becoming obvious that in addition to the contraction of global demand, as well as the general increase in the relative competitiveness of other Asian countries, China’s rapid rise was coming to a screeching halt and leaving excessive debt in its wake.  


In recent weeks, the Chinese market experienced its biggest weekly fall in 20 years, tumbling more than 15%. This volatility serves as a further warning: China is still an emerging market, and it has an immature financial system.

Excessive debt


Excessive debt is infecting every sector of China’s economy, from real estate and local governments to state-run or partially government-controlled companies. 


Most large companies in China were on a roll for a number of years, in large part thanks to subsidies from the government. But, at the same time, they were not accruing capital because their activities were so dependent on subsidies. Chinese banks, which are mainly controlled by the Communist party, compounded matters by giving credit at artificially low interest rates fueling excessive debt in all of the country’s sectors. 


Many of China’s largescale development projects are perfect examples of how excessive debt has piled up. Infrastructure projects, funded by subsidized loans with low interest rates, yield low profitability and weak capital productivity. Much of this credit is given through a system called "shadow banking", meaning it does not go through normal bank loans; credit products are sold directly to individuals.


Public sector debt, particularly at the local and regional levels, has been enormous. They have gotten in their current predicament by over-relying on infrastructure projects. This cannot last forever as there are only so many roads one can build. 

Demography and environment woes


China also has a number of other problems on top of its high level of debt and low capital productivity. Due to the one child policy being in place for so long, its massive elderly population will have to be sustained by a much smaller working population. Social spending by the state will only increase exponentially, especially on education and health. The Chinese government also has a very high budget deficit. It is officially estimated to be at 3% or more in 2016, but how high it will really climb is anyone’s guess. 


Last but not least, the country’s environmental problems are a well-known major burden to China and the rest of the world. Anyone who’s ever been to or seen pictures from Beijing is familiar with the city’s residents making their way around the city in anti-pollution masks. 


Chinese authorities face some very tough choices ahead. China is currently exhibiting many “rich country” problems while it has the budget of a “poor country”. A structural reform of its tax system is now clearly needed; its current system is archaic and biased. No country can have its cake and eat it too. If China wants a market economy, then it must understand that intervening in markets is bound to fail, and it must learn to accept the volatility that comes with any open market economy. The volatility we are currently experiencing in the markets only confirms what many already know: Beijing doesn’t have that much control over the economy anyways. 


In the coming years, China will most likely go through a very similar scenario as Europe has in the years after financial crisis -- serious restructuring in Chinese business models and banks’ balance sheets. This does not mean that the Chinese economy will collapse. Far from it, we will see much lower growth rates, but there will still be growth.

Contained effects


China’s sheer size and role on the global stage means that its problems will create risk for the global economy. However, don’t expect a crisis of 2008-2009 proportions. Any damage China will cause will be relatively contained. 

注:Nuno Fernandes是瑞士洛桑国际管理学院(IMD)的金融学教授,其在该学院负责战略金融课程、高管财务管理课程,以及IMD新推出的"Global Leadership in the Cloud"  课程。此外,他还著有《高管之金融:管理者的实用手册》一书。

Nuno Fernandes is Professor of Finance at IMD, where he directs the Strategic Finance program and also Finance Fundamentals for Executives, a new IMD "Global Leadership in the Cloud" program. He is the author of Finance for Executives: A Practical Guide for Managers.


我们鼓励所有读者在我们的文章和博客上分享意见。We are committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion, so we ask you to avoid personal attacks, and please keep your comments relevant and respectful. Visit the FAQ page for more information.